Fears to Fathom: Scratch Creek Stuck Fixes

Universal Reset Checklist

Use this before restarting the whole run.

1. 1Bring Marcus and Tessa back to the same landmark.
2. 2Have both players inspect the last objective object, door, vehicle, phone, or NPC.
3. 3Read the latest phone messages out loud.
4. 4Walk back to the previous named location, then return to the current objective.
5. 5If one player is desynced, reload the latest checkpoint together.

Gas Station or Repair Shop Not Progressing

A Reddit launch-window report described players reaching the gas station area after car trouble and not getting the next event to fire. Treat this as a trigger checklist.

• Park or stop near the intended repair/motel area rather than far down the road.
• Have both players leave the car and inspect the building entrances, shop area, and nearby interactables.
• Do not drive away immediately after arriving; some events depend on both players being present.
• If nothing happens after a full sweep, reload the latest checkpoint and repeat the arrival more slowly.

Church Basement Confusion

The church basement is meant to feel disorienting. The important reveal is that Marcus can end up in the wrong basement or tunnel system, so do not assume every locked door is a bug.

• Check for alternate exits and tunnel paths before backtracking.
• Use texts to keep Tessa informed when Marcus is locked in.
• Look for hiding spaces and narrow passages rather than only main doors.
• If the door state differs between players, regroup after the next checkpoint.

Final Chase and Trailer Problems

The finale punishes hesitation. Decide the trailer plan before the chase reaches the car.

• If the trailer blocks escape, focus both players on the same interaction instead of splitting objectives.
• Use hiding spots only to break line of sight, not as a permanent safe room.
• After each death, call out the exact turn or object that failed.
• If repeated deaths feel inconsistent, restart from the checkpoint to clear possible sync drift.